Wilhelm Schmidt (1868-1954) was a German anthropologist, linguist, ethnologist, and Catholic priest well-known for his study of languages, cultures, and religions of so-called “primitive” peoples. He is also remembered for his notion of primordial monotheism.
Schmidt became critical of evolutionary theories that attempted to ground traditional monotheistic religious belief, which lent well into his hypothesis that numerous primitive peoples believed in and worshiped a Supreme Being. He was therefore particularly critical of evolutionist accounts proposed by E. B. Tylor, Herbert Spencer, and other developmentalists. Schmidt did not agree that later religious belief developed from, say, animism or polytheism into monotheism.
Schmidt proposed quite a different notion altogether. He argued that the earliest human beings believed in a Supreme Being, and that monotheism (the belief in one supreme God) was not late in the development of religious consciousness. Rather, to the contrary, monotheism represented the earliest beliefs about deity, and, as Schmidt believed, there was monotheism before there was ever polytheism. Polytheism is the belief in the existence of many deities, but Schmidt saw such belief as a degenerated state of monotheism. Similarly, he stated how the idea of a Supreme Being was degraded into other religious phenomena such as ancestor worship, fertility cults, magic, and so on. Schmidt explained his ideas in detail in his 12 volume work Der Ursprung der Gottesidee (1912-1955). He notes the religions of primitive hunter-gatherers such as the Pygmy tribes and contends that monotheistic views were expressed within them. This led him to propose the idea of primordial monotheism, the term he used to refer to the earliest religions that could be considered monotheistic.
Schmidt examined the concept further and reasoned to characteristics of deity that were strikingly similar to that of the Christian God. For instance, he noted the eternality of God (that God existed before all other things were brought into existence), and God’s omniscience, omnipotence, and authority to punish evil and reward good behaviour. This God was also a creator. Schmidt noted that the name “creator” did not occur much among the primitive peoples although they did reference a deity’s power to create,
“Comparing the primitive cultures with the later ones, we may lay down the general principle that in none of the latter is the Supreme Being to be found in so clear, so definite, vivid, and direct a form as among peoples belonging to the former. We may now proceed to supplement this by another of no less importance. This Supreme Being is to be found among all the peoples of the primitive culture, not indeed everywhere in the same form… but still everywhere prominent enough to make his dominant position indubitable.”
It seems that Schmidt was primarily motivated to affirm that the God the primitive peoples and tribes believed in and acknowledged was the same God that the Christians worshiped. Schmidt believed that the one, true God was later more fully revealed in Jesus Christ and within the Christian narrative. His hope was therefore to secure a place for Christian theological interpretation in the history of religious consciousness.
Schmidt, W. Der Ursprung der Gottesidee. p. 257.
[…] were believed in by the earliest historical peoples. However, unlike the scholar by the name Wilhelm Schmidt (1868-1954), Pettazzoni did not wish to argue for an original monotheism or, as Schmidt did, for a […]
[…] experiences of powerful people onto a supernatural realm. The German anthropologist and ethnologist Wilhelm Schmidt (1868-1954) argued that the earliest religious belief was in Supreme Being, and that monotheism (the […]
[…] Catholic priest and anthropologist Wilhelm Schmidt (1868-1954) claimed that there was a widespread belief in a High God existing “behind” or “above” the multitude […]
As I noted in my book, MYTH CONCEPTIONS, Schmidt actually refuted Pettazzoni’s major points. Pettazzoni’s criticisms are therefore not valid.
[…] believe in God. Some have argued that animism explains the rise of religions, whereas others note a primordial monotheism or polytheism. The atheist who makes the argument from HADD who does not acknowledge other […]
[…] of religion’s primordium (origin) and of its earliest beliefs as did Jean Bodin (1530-1596), Wilhelm Schmidt (1868-1954), and […]
[…] from polytheism. This is not an accepted theory today and not all historical theorists agreed; Wilhelm Schmidt (1868-1954), for example, posited a primordial monotheism as the earliest form of religious belief […]