A Christian Argument for Jesus Mythicism.


Most Christians don’t actually realize the strength of the Jesus mythicist’s arguments in modern academia nowadays. According to un-referenced statistics, provided by the research conglomerate The Atheist Empire, only 3% of historians believe Jesus existed.  I outline, albeit briefly, why I think this is a rational position. I use the above nonsensical pro-Christian meme as an example.

Hey guys, since we made up that Jesus guy and everything he did and said…”

Don’t deny it! Richard Carrier and Robert Price know what they are talking about. They are top scholars in their field. They’re just some of those multitudes of historians that deny Jesus ever existed (you did know that this is the consensus of modern scholarship? Just ask any historian). There isn’t any evidence, not one bit, that Jesus actually ever existed (I  heard Dawkins say this once, and I found that the more I repeat this to myself the more convincing it sounds). And all that evidence that actually exists is all copied from those mythical dying and rising gods! Didn’t you know Mithras also had a virgin birth even though it was actually from a rock? But the concept is almost identical (just ignore the rock part).

Let’s all really stick to our story.”

The disciples, the Apostle Paul, and James were severely deluded if they ever thought that inventing Jesus would bring them great wealth and prestige (Even though their invented Jesus spoke directly against such motives, Mat. 16:26)! In fact, a serious argument can be made that the disciples were so convincing that it would probably account for all the alleged post-mortem resurrection appearances of Jesus to Paul, James, the disciples, and the 500 others.

Let’s leave our homes and make uncomfortable journeys, be marginalized, and end up being killed in horrific ways…”

Remember, there isn’t a shred of evidence to suggest that any of them died for their convictions either. And the claim that they would make “uncomfortable journeys” and be “be marginalized.” Where’s the evidence for that? You can’t refer to the gospels, Acts, or Paul because they don’t count. Referring to the Bible would be like referring to Homer’s Iliad (even though I haven’t’ read the Iliad, but atheists at Richard Carrier’s blogsite often mention it in the comment section).

And don’t refer to the ancient historians Tacitus or Josephus (or any other ancient historian that seems to have mentioned Jesus)! There’s no evidence that they ever mentioned Jesus at all. And where they do those are all Christian interpolations (bits added in afterwards).

It will be the best joke ever.”

Yes, the meme is actually correct; Christianity is the biggest joke ever. If we never had Christianity there wouldn’t have been the crusades, inquisitions, and all those witch hunts! We don’t need religion to be moral. And that over two billion people would put faith in someone who never ever existed! Did I mention that neuroscientists have found faith to be an actual mental illness? But I’ll get to that next time, instead I’ll end off with a quote from the Symposium of Anti-Biblical Exegesis:

“That the 1st century Jesus Christ existed (an assumption that has dictated much of modern scholarship) is now being questioned by an ever increasing number of top scholars because no evidence exists. The Symposium of Anti-Biblical Exegesis is now providing research grants for experts interested in pursuing this subject further. An official statement will be drafted in the second half of 2016” (1).


1. Quoted in an interview with Sean Fracek, founder of The Mythicist Milwaukee.

PS: Any real people mentioned in this article is purely unintentional.


10 responses to “A Christian Argument for Jesus Mythicism.

  1. Is this a joke post? I actually cannot tell. if not…

    3%? No offense, but are you actually stupid? Historians are in complete unanimous agreement (99%+) that Jesus existed. Please do not spread such utter nonsense. I can name 100 historians who believe Jesus existed for every one that you can name that doesn’t (more then a B.A., of course, otherwise from my knowledge I can only name like 50 per 1 you can name). What is this “Atheist Empire” garbage?

  2. One of the biggest proof statements is that without Christianity there would have been no Crusades’s or inquisitions. Well of course there wouldn’t under the guise of a religion that has at its core ‘judgement’ and ‘hatred’ of enemies aka Christianity! Jesus had said “kill your enemies wherever you find them.” But would there be violence and oppression under another name? Under communism and dictatorships, Nth Korea for example: Everything is so peaceful and people are living in happiness and prosperity wherever religion is eradicated or oppressed. (For those who lack frontal lobes this is sarcasm.)

  3. could you give the hindu argument against the idea that Krishna is a myth? or Odin?

    You do realize that not everything we know for truth is true? The land of the free and the home of the brave? Of course… if you don’t consider black people to be slaves and women to be people and you haven’t read the hysterical blaming that claimed that King George sent “murdering savages” to attack the colonies. Or how about “I cannot tell a lie”. (or the gun nutters who think that everyone is out to get them so they must be armed like they are in some third world war torn area like Somalia).

    Or how about the confederate flag/the south shall rise morons who claim that the civil war was about “states rights” even after you show them that the states quite explicitly indicated that it was for the preservation of slavery? Or how about the Christians who babble about “America is a Christian nation based on biblical principles” when they are confronted with the infamous treaty of Tripoli article? Just how is Barton not laughed out of any honest christian setting?

    Of course, when we grow up, we aren’t upset when those “truths” are revealed to be untruths. An honest person will acknowledge the veracity that the civil war was based on the confederate states wanting to preserve slavery. An honest person would stop lying and claiming that the US was founded on Christian principles. They would revise their knowledge and incorporate the new information.

    However, religion can form a core concept of one’s identity. That’s why, there is emotional upset when somebody comes by and says “the Jesus that is described in the Bible is a made up creation”. Why do you think one of the greatest insults to give to a man is to imply that he is a female? Or vice versa. You are attacking the core identity and that is different from the non-core identity.

    Think about it –

    would you accept this guy?

    1. He is the second person of the Trinity
    2. Called the son of God
    3. human father was a carpenter
    4. healed a leper
    5. raised the dead
    6. fasted in the wilderness
    7. conceived by a Spirit/Ghost
    8. fled because the local king wanted to kill the infant

    I know that I don’t. It seems very shady and inconsistent with the reality that everybody has observed.

    Look – I have no problem with claiming that a “jesus” prophet existed. He probably taught the same things that Rabbi Hillel taught on and expanded on them. That makes sense. Hell, I have relatives who are named Joshua (equivalent name to Jesus) and i’m sure there’s a jesus running around in spanish harlem. But the guy described in the bible? That’s pushing it.

    In reference to the list of attributes listed above –

    It’s a trick question. I listed the attributes ascribed to Lord Krishna, a hindu deity. But if you thought – Jesus for every single attribute, why don’t you accept that the Hindu’s worship a real god as well? Or rather, why is Krishna not afforded the same status and is considered “demonic” or “myth” whereas Jesus is not? Please no petty crap or quibbles with grammar or the like. Fair and equal treatment for both or for neither. And at least I’m consistent. I reject both Jesus and Krishna as demi-god/god whatevers.

Let me know your thoughts!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s